Stranger Things heartthrob Joe Keery is once again at the center of Hollywood dating chatter — this time linked to pop star Sabrina Carpenter. Romance rumours between the two have been swirling for months, but their recent appearance at the Saturday Night Live after-party in New York City has reignited fan excitement and speculation.
The star-studded after-party followed Stranger Things actor Finn Wolfhard’s hosting debut on SNL, making it a special reunion night for the show’s cast. Although Joe and Sabrina arrived separately, fans were quick to notice that both attended the same exclusive event. Their coinciding appearances were enough to send social media into detective mode, especially since neither has confirmed nor denied the dating rumours.
Videos and photos circulating online captured Sabrina stepping out of her car as flashing cameras surrounded her. The “Espresso” singer looked effortlessly chic in a long black coat, her blonde hair framing her face as she greeted photographers. Meanwhile, Joe Keery made his entrance in his signature casual-cool style — a black leather jacket, grey jeans, knit cap, and sunglasses completing his look. Despite not walking in together, their separate arrivals only added fuel to the romance buzz.
This isn’t the first time the pair has caused a frenzy among fans. In October 2024, during Sabrina’s performance at the Austin City Limits festival, she spotted Joe in the audience and decided to have a little fun. Pausing mid-show, she joked, “Joe, it’s cuffing season; I don’t know if you know that,” before tossing pink handcuffs toward him. Joe — who also performs music under the name DJo — playfully extended his wrists in response. The moment went viral within hours, convincing fans that there might be more than friendship between them.
Sabrina Carpenter and Joe Keery, aka the guy she arrested for being too hot, arrive at the SNL afterparty 🤭 pic.twitter.com/gj1a5Vqu1e
— sylvia (@ohhowromantic) January 18, 2026
Despite these playful public interactions, both stars have remained tight-lipped about their relationship status. Their silence has only deepened curiosity, leaving fans guessing whether this is a budding romance or simply a fun friendship.
Joe Keery was previously in a long-term relationship with actress Maika Monroe. The couple dated for five years before calling it quits in 2022. Sabrina Carpenter, on the other hand, was linked to actor Barry Keoghan, though reports suggest they parted ways in 2024 after a year together.
For now, the true nature of Joe and Sabrina’s relationship remains unknown. Whether they are Hollywood’s newest couple or just friends enjoying the spotlight, fans are eagerly watching for the next clue. Until then, their SNL after-party appearance and viral stage moment continue to keep the rumour mill spinning.